Games likeMidnight Mayhem
Tap a tag once for more of it, twice for none of it.
ObscureFrightened
61% matchOnline Co-Op, Survival Horror, Similar premise
AAJohn Carpenter's Toxic Commando
56% matchOften compared to it, Online Co-Op, Supernatural
AADark Hours
60% matchOnline Co-Op, Supernatural, Similar premise
ObscureDirge
58% matchOnline Co-Op, Supernatural, Similar premise
ObscureThere Won't be Light
56% matchOnline Co-Op, Psychological Horror, Similar premise
AAShift At Midnight
58% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror, Similar premise
ObscureCreepless
56% matchStealth, Online Co-Op, Similar premise
ObscureBloody Forest
60% matchSupernatural, Online Co-Op
IndieStorebound
54% matchOnline Co-Op, Supernatural
ObscureHaunted Halloween
58% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
ObscureDisembowel
60% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror
ObscureDemonsomnia
54% matchOnline Co-Op, Supernatural
IndieSpecies: Unknown
54% matchOnline Co-Op, Stealth
ObscureMothman
56% matchOnline Co-Op, Psychological Horror, Similar premise
ObscureBackrooms: The Phobolore
53% matchSurvival Horror, Horror
ObscureShadows in Silence
55% matchOnline Co-Op, Stealth
ObscureBACKROOMS: DON'T LOOK AWAY
52% matchSupernatural, Horror, Similar premise
AAPANICORE
58% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror
AAYAPYAP
52% matchOnline Co-Op, Comedy
ObscureHorror Night
50% matchSupernatural, Online Co-Op, Similar premise
AALabyrinthine
52% matchOnline Co-Op, Supernatural, Similar premise
ObscureNIGHT CROW
51% matchOnline Co-Op, Supernatural
AAParanormal Cleanup
53% matchOften compared to it, Online Co-Op, Stealth
ObscureBackrooms: Hide Together
53% matchOnline Co-Op, Survival Horror, Similar premise
ObscureWicked Dolls
53% matchSupernatural, Online Co-Op
IndieHorror Squad
55% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op
ObscurePONE
56% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror
ObscureTogether After Dark
51% matchHorror, Psychological Horror, Similar premise
ObscureCamp Wombo
53% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op, Similar premise
AAGTFO
53% matchOften compared to it, Online Co-Op, Co-op
AABackrooms: Escape Together
57% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror
ObscureMayhemers
45% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op, Similar premise
ObscureNight Shippers
50% matchOnline Co-Op, Supernatural
ObscureMISTERY
48% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op, Similar premise
AADark Hours: Prologue
58% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror, Similar premise
ObscureMidnight Murder Club
45% matchCo-op, Horror
ObscureA Way To Be Dead
49% matchStealth, Survival Horror, Similar premise
ObscureDark Home
52% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror, Similar premise
ObscureHEARTDUST
49% matchOnline Co-Op, Psychological Horror
ObscureSilent Rain
55% matchOnline Co-Op, Survival Horror, Similar premise
IndieSecret Neighbor: Hello Neighbor Multiplayer
50% matchOnline Co-Op, Stealth, Similar premise
ObscureDeath Swap: End As One
54% matchOnline Co-Op, Survival Horror
ObscureSkeleton Hell
49% matchSupernatural, Comedy, Similar premise
ObscureWALKER
51% matchOnline Co-Op, Survival Horror
ObscureHorror Simulator VR: Prologue
48% matchOnline Co-Op, Co-op, Similar premise
ObscureUnemployed Nightmare Together
48% matchOnline Co-Op, Horror
IndieMidnight Ghost Hunt
45% matchSupernatural, FPS, Similar premise
ObscureOn Dark Terms
47% matchSupernatural, Co-op